Script of Charity
For no reason that bears scrutiny I have, on my side of the window, food – food you seek with “Please”, food I pass to you, and you say “Thank you” (then our smiles), and then I say, “You’re welcome.” The script of charity assigns your lines: "Please." “If it pleases you." “You can give or withhold. I hope to please you with my ‘Please’.” (Of course there’s no withholding – I’m here to give. But I can have attitude, be impatient, grouchy, rough – and still give lunch, feel “helping” and get thanked.) You say, “Thank you.” “I hope my gratitude means I can ask again tomorrow, ‘If you please.’” And my line, also assigned: “You’re welcome” says, “Yes. You can.” It’s the script of charity – the default of good people, but not innocent. Even less innocent, someone says, “Beggars can’t be choosers.” But isn’t it our choosing makes us human, isn’t agency our ...